Academic outsourcing

Though co-authorship between leading academics and graduate students is common, and can often be of mutual benefit, it is reasonable to expect the professor in question to make a substantial contribution to the end product - especially if they are the lead author.

A key issue is how much credit should be given those who do the hard slog of gathering the evidence and crunching the numbers? When co-writing papers I have always insisted they be the lead author, but I suspect this is often not the case. This paragraph from an article by Jacob Hale Russell in magazine 02138, A Million Little Writers, caught my eye:

One of academia’s up-and-coming darlings is Roland Fryer, an assistant professor in the economics department who began teaching at Harvard just last year. Fryer is a media star: He has appeared on CNN and been written about in the New York Times, Esquire, and this issue of 02138 (see page 34). Fryer’s group, the American Inequality Lab, works on a half-dozen or more major research areas at a time. To do so, Fryer now employs seven full-time “project managers,” mostly recent college alums, and works with dozens of others. The students, generally recent college graduates like David Toniatti, each manage a research project, from designing the methodology to collecting the data and running the numbers. Fryer writes the final papers, for which he is accorded primary authorship. “It’s him casting a vision, us working through the details, and him correcting it,” Toniatti says. “Everyone can run the regression; it’s really the idea that counts.”

I am sure what goes on at Harvard's American Inequality Lab is quite common, and that many economic professors engage in such 'atelier' practices. And at least Fryer is said to write the final papers. But to what extent should such academic outsourcing be accredited? Is co-authorship enough? Comments welcome - especially if you have been party to these kind of arrangements yourself.

UPDATE: Tim Harford links to this post at his FT Undercover Economist blog, and comments:

This makes perfect sense to me, but the 02138 article also lays out some of the risks and problems of too much outsourcing. Roland Fryer, incidentally, is a very impressive figure and features in The Logic of Life. Stephen Dubner (co-author of Freakonomics) wrote a truly astonishing profile of him here - if you never read anything about an economist every again, at least read that.

Comments

[Some physics dude]

In physics, generally the lab leader (with a job analagous to Fryer) is the last name on the paper. The general understanding is that he provides guidance, while the students do much of the grunt work. The order of the names of the students indicates who did more of the grunt work.

If all authors made an equal contribution, alphabetical. Sometimes (especially in PRL, since their LaTex style makes this the default), by institution, then alphabetical within the institution.

Math people tend to do everything alphabetical.

[jsalvati]

As someone who will probably be an econ graduate student soon, I think Fryer's approach is totally appropriate. The people with the idea should be most credited; don't we prize ideas more than gruntwork abilities in scientists?

[Ace]

"As someone who will probably be an econ graduate student soon, I think Fryer's approach is totally appropriate. The people with the idea should be most credited; don't we prize ideas more than gruntwork abilities in scientists?

Posted by: jsalvati"

I don't think this is acceptable at all. NOT everybody can do the regressions, it takes lots of hard work to put together the the evidence and make the regressions work. I have got my PhD in Econ and have done a lot of the data crunching, my experience is that the one who has done most writing / most data crunching comes in the front, those who have merely provided comments / advices / guidance comes in the back. I have looked at one of Fryer's paper - the idea and concept isn't that new and he has conveniently (like many US academics mind you) forget to quote their fellow folks across the pond who have been working on the same area.

[Arthur Eckart]

In economics, you can outsource regressions. However, you can't outsource ideas. So, it seems, ideas, whether big or small, are more important. Of course, big ideas, e.g. the Linder Effect (link below) are more influencial.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linder_hypothesis

[JD]

About Roland Fryer

"Roland Fryer, incidentally, is a very impressive figure..."

I don't know much about this economist but at first sight, I can't find anything impressive about him. He looks like a regular mainstream economist, conveying regular mainstream ideas. I can't see why this guy is presented as the next revolution in human science. Can someone enlight me? I would say a priori that these kind of ideas reflect so much common sense in the U.S. that they could be outsourced rather easily.

JD.

[Jasmine Rose]

As a member of the University Faculty, I have read and was inspired by a visitor editorial1in these pages a few years ago that I kept in my office. In the assessment of writing, Recently, I observed a practice that has the potential to become an imbalance in our work, a practice, I will describe how academic outsourcing.

Outsourcing occurs when a company buys goods or services from an external source, rather than the production of goods or the provision of services "in-house". For example, General Motors (GM) have outsourcing, if it has a component of one of its mini-vans by a non-GMO manufacturer's instructions. This practice has been celebrated as one of the means for improving the cost-effectiveness of the management and enable enterprises to remain competitive, although defendant as a potential cause of job insecurity by workers.

I think the term can also be used in the academic community from physical therapy, to describe the practice of the Faculty to provide additions to the "goods". Representative of the ability to work as a visiting professor, laboratories and instructors lab examiners, and, of course, to serve as coordinators. If this practice, a place in the exhibition of a curriculum of physical therapy? The speed of answer is "yes". "You can immediately see a number of positive results. Often, the complement of the Faculty are practicing physical therapists. Students have expressed interest irritated, if a teacher is practicing therapist, to be grounded in the day-to-date clinical experience supply. profession and the additional faculty member to benefit, because it is a mechanism for the transition between hospital and the classroom. Clinicians may be additional academic opportunity to try before we have a career of teaching. These facilitate the movement in the academic world, the positions often cited lack Faculty of physical therapists.

For the institution, the benefits of the use of the Adjunct Faculty are tangible. In our Institute, Faculty Supplement are paid less than a quarter of the salary of a full-time job on the faculty to teach the same three courses of performance. As Adjunct Faculty are, in general, with only symbolic benefits, is cheap, the savings for the establishment are even more dramatic. Representative of the Faculty often receive no fixed desk, no technician does not have the resources for research (Land Management, peripherals, time, resources), and there is no real commitment to the Faculty development opportunities. As a result, academic institutions, as well as the company subcontracts, the profits from the reduction or elimination of many of the costs associated with benefits in relation to the finished product. Representative of the Faculty are a real price.

I think, a realistic assessment of costs is necessary. Representative of the Faculty are not always in the business, full-time faculty members and conducting at the University of the division operates as in the working committees and task forces and academic and professional advice. Full-time faculty can also expect formal or informal, to provide additional aid University Faculty in the context of management. This may include advice on the classification, the checks carried out, in writing, the classroom and teaching management techniques, and maybe even the hours and unexpected absences. The result was a decision to increase the use of the Adjunct Faculty has the very real potential in an item in the obligations of the faculty full time. As a small, but concrete, hypothetical example, if 250 physical therapists students need a physical therapy faculty advisors, and they are 10 full-time teachers, while each member of the faculty to work with 25 advisees . But if members of the Faculty 5 (full-time), without debate, Adjunct Faculty responsibilities, then everything else full-time were 50 teachers advise students. Such examples can be attendance at cinemas, recruits, and many other academic responsibilities.

I would therefore urge caution in the implementation of the earth complement instructors, ifthe main objective is to reduce costs. The widespread use of the option in a surplus in May of the net reduction in the yield of full-time or nuclear weapons, of the Faculty. The supporting role of full-time teachers to play in this scenario are rarely informed and a work plan and a reduction in teaching, research or administration and / or clinical practice of each member's full-time Faculty. This practice can also help, stress and loss of balance Mr. Stith so brilliantly described. The possible reduction in the productivity of full-time faculty is probably not enthusiastically by faculty members or to improve their capacity, the mandate and the promotion deserve. The same applies if the department or institution as a whole can be seen as effective (cheapest), the large-scale deployment of this practice.

[burun estetiği]

Academic outsourcing

I can't see why this guy is presented as the next revolution in human science. Can someone enlight me? I would say a priori that these kind of ideas reflect so much common sense in the U.S. that they could be outsourced rather easily.

[Lead Generation Philippines]

You cannot outsource ideas most definitely. It's something that you cannot take credit for.

[rolex daytona]

I don't know much about this economist but at first sight, I can't find anything impressive about him. He looks like a regular mainstream economist, conveying regular mainstream ideas. I can't see why this guy is presented as the next revolution in human science. Can someone enlight me? I would say a priori that these kind of ideas reflect so much common sense in the U.S. that they could be outsourced rather easily.

[rolex submariner]

thanks for you share ,i like so much,It is so lucky to read your blog,it is full of useful message

[Telemarketing]

Now, this is an interesting subject. The grueling work of researching and cataloguing can be outsourced but can an idea be? I don't think so. Like what lead generation phil said - you cannot take credit for an idea.

[Telemarketing Services]

Too much outsourcing may post risks. You also have to study whether or not a service can really benefit you or pose problems in the future. However, there is no doubt about the benefits and the advantages that outsourcing provides.

[Impotence causes]

To begin I would like to send a cordial greeting to all readers of this blog. Hello my name is David, I am a physical therapist for 6 years, I love reading all the articles that are related to all type of therapy, it seems very relevant to the importance of a good therapy in any recovery. Anything can serve therapy, a landscape, a holiday, a pet food, etc.. I would like more information like this, no doubt will be eagerly awaiting your next article. thanks ..

[Cheap viagra]

Hello to all readers, my name is Richard, is a pleasure for me to share my opinion, a few years ago I attended a conference called Cheap viagra, this conference was really very interesting, I'm naming it reminds me of the theme of this blog, thank you very much for sharing this informción with us!

[cheap jordans]

It is my great honor to have the chance to look throught the nice and informative posts.Thank you for sharing with us a go!

[air jordan]

The new post of your blog is defintely stunning!I enjoy your blog quite a lot and at the same time, gain great benificial from that.

[air yeezys]

The thing that oneself like to grasping, strive for, no regrets!

[Generic Cialis]

I would like to appreciate the great work done by You

Please continue posting like this

[air max]

My favorite.

[GHD]

successHerve Leger dressesexpect
Herve Leger clothingearly

make sureHerve Leger clothing
desired piecesDiscount herve leger in minutes
eleganceChristian Louboutin SandalsThe creative vision
let me downChristian Louboutin Sandals Sale

leatherPrada SunglassesTalented artist
Oakley Sunglassesluxury
appealArmani Sunglassesthe most exciting

a href="http://www.designersunglasses-glasses.com/bvlgari-sunglasses-c-46.html">Bvlgari suglasses salethe detail
reallyBvlgari suglassesSpain
Cheap Bvlgari suglasses on slae

Martini Sunglassesed hardy kid tshirtsthe players
Ed Hardy Men Beach Pants
ed hardy hoodiesdisplay

a href="http://www.cheap-ed-hardy-clothing.com/ed-hardy-sunglasses-c-14.html">Cheap ed hardy sunglassesOne day
hardy clothingCheap ed hardy WomenApparently

ShopCheap Herve Leger Dressesthis summer
Discount Herve Leger Dressesmany times
my listHerve Leger Skirtall time

this reasonCheap Herve Leger Dress 2010well-known design
classifiedCheap Herve Leger Saleforever

a fewWomen Christian Audigier BagsApple floods

annually Women Christian Audigier Underwear
Women Christian Audigier Walletslogical

a piece of Christian Audigier Women Purses Discountthe pie
Christian Audigier Women Caps Discountfashion
Christian Audigier Women Hoodies Discountdaily

humanMBT Sandalswhy
questions MBT Sports Shoespanda
spend all day MBT Casual On Saleshopping

First offMBT SapatuGreen
United StatesWomen MBT Sapatu Sandalsconsumers
MBT Sapatu Men Sandals On Saleindustry

responsiblelouboutin pumps saleplanet
the environmentlouboutin shoes salebut also
pictureslouboutin boots saleshare

charmsMen Louboutin Shoesactivelytwo eras mightChristian Louboutin men sneakersextremelyin commonChristian loubout shoes discount salecollection

talking aboutDiscount Ghd Straightenerspecifically
Ghd Hair Straighteners Cheaplook like springGhd Hair Straighteners Cheapsport hardingBlue Serenity GHD IV Stylerstudentthe richDark GHD IV StylerteacherGHD Benefit StylershootsadnessHerve Leger Dress Discountdiscovery themeDiscount Herve Leger Dressstyler

fashionableDiscount Herve leger Bandage Dressincredible

sponserHerve Leger Clothing Cheapsurvival
encourageHerve Leger Clothing On Salelight
tell me truthDiscount Herve Leger Skirtdarling
a href="http://www.ugg-uk-australia.com/">ugg ukmistake
kateugg australiasomewhere
lineugg boots on salecan
theyuggs boots ukkinds
all bestuggs australiatheme

memoryugg 5359throw up
give meugg 1873its up to you
skyugg 5885closely

[GHD]

successHerve Leger dressesexpect
Herve Leger clothingearly

make sureHerve Leger clothing
desired piecesDiscount herve leger in minutes
eleganceChristian Louboutin SandalsThe creative vision
let me downChristian Louboutin Sandals Sale

leatherPrada SunglassesTalented artist
Oakley Sunglassesluxury
appealArmani Sunglassesthe most exciting

a href="http://www.designersunglasses-glasses.com/bvlgari-sunglasses-c-46.html">Bvlgari suglasses salethe detail
reallyBvlgari suglassesSpain
Cheap Bvlgari suglasses on slae

Martini Sunglassesed hardy kid tshirtsthe players
Ed Hardy Men Beach Pants
ed hardy hoodiesdisplay

a href="http://www.cheap-ed-hardy-clothing.com/ed-hardy-sunglasses-c-14.html">Cheap ed hardy sunglassesOne day
hardy clothingCheap ed hardy WomenApparently

ShopCheap Herve Leger Dressesthis summer
Discount Herve Leger Dressesmany times
my listHerve Leger Skirtall time

this reasonCheap Herve Leger Dress 2010well-known design
classifiedCheap Herve Leger Saleforever

a fewWomen Christian Audigier BagsApple floods

annually Women Christian Audigier Underwear
Women Christian Audigier Walletslogical

a piece of Christian Audigier Women Purses Discountthe pie
Christian Audigier Women Caps Discountfashion
Christian Audigier Women Hoodies Discountdaily

humanMBT Sandalswhy
questions MBT Sports Shoespanda
spend all day MBT Casual On Saleshopping

First offMBT SapatuGreen
United StatesWomen MBT Sapatu Sandalsconsumers
MBT Sapatu Men Sandals On Saleindustry

responsiblelouboutin pumps saleplanet
the environmentlouboutin shoes salebut also
pictureslouboutin boots saleshare

charmsMen Louboutin Shoesactivelytwo eras mightChristian Louboutin men sneakersextremelyin commonChristian loubout shoes discount salecollection

talking aboutDiscount Ghd Straightenerspecifically
Ghd Hair Straighteners Cheaplook like springGhd Hair Straighteners Cheapsport hardingBlue Serenity GHD IV Stylerstudentthe richDark GHD IV StylerteacherGHD Benefit StylershootsadnessHerve Leger Dress Discountdiscovery themeDiscount Herve Leger Dressstyler

fashionableDiscount Herve leger Bandage Dressincredible

sponserHerve Leger Clothing Cheapsurvival
encourageHerve Leger Clothing On Salelight
tell me truthDiscount Herve Leger Skirtdarling
a href="http://www.ugg-uk-australia.com/">ugg ukmistake
kateugg australiasomewhere
lineugg boots on salecan
theyuggs boots ukkinds
all bestuggs australiatheme

memoryugg 5359throw up
give meugg 1873its up to you
skyugg 5885closely

[Uggs Outlet]

Love.love.love.

[Video Surveillance]

It seems to be a little alike my case, I am a International Relations Student and also work at the "International Relations Magazine" from college as Editor's assistent.

Along with my assistent job I have to be available to help any person that will be published.. so I usually am in the middle of conferences, gathering materials, reading books, magazanes, asking and analysing stadistical data and, at the end, reading and rewriting articles if necessary..

So, I don't complain about it because I like it, but After I while I think my name should be on the magazine as well!!

[Web Services]

This is a problem.. severe problem...

I have been working at college nd doing some research about asia's economy and impact... but I realize What I 've been doing, I proffesor is taking my research and other classmates to write about it...
I don't think taking others analysis, comments and reseach could be a good ethical practice!!!!

[kavitasyon]

This blog must not be real, because not all these books were available at the time the library issue of rewriting policies was being discussed. I think this blog is false and only pretending to be Sarah.

[horkes]

Remove it from the loud sound described as among the People of the individual during sleep, especially in the medical sense, the most common cause of snoring soft palate observed in adults, little more than normal growth of the tongue, the muscles sag and lose tension and blockage of the airway during sleep titresmesidir little of the language.

[true religion outlet]

LO LO LO LO.....Has been very quiet, to give you love has been very quiet, you say you love like a cloud, to float freely until beautiful.....

[True Religion Outlet]

I am sure what goes on at Harvard's American Inequality Lab is quite common, and that many economic professors engage in such 'atelier' practices. And at least Fryer is said to write the final papers. But to what extent should such academic outsourcing be accredited? Is co-authorship enough? Comments welcome - especially if you have been party to these kind of arrangements yourself.

[Generic Viagra]

Hey, Really great work,I would like to join your blog anyway so please continue sharing with us...

[sac çikarici]

Internet users in more than 2 billion people worldwide, 778 million the number of computers registered to the internet, the web of 313 million, a total of 205 million units in the name of that reported.

To the extent that there is hundreds of millions of blogs and video Ahmed, said that Turkey has been estimated that there's at around 30 million.

Ahmed, the computer recorded the number of Internet in Turkey has been reported around 4 million, 250 thousand under .. en told that the domain name.

[diş beyazlatma kalemi]

Save the essence of life in the treatment of skin allantoinle Snail! This essence creates a bad appearance and have no choice tahribatlarının skin no longer be removed even if the so-called cracks.

Nature of this herbal solution effectively and safely as possible to get rid of sivilcelerinizden! Skin care products on behalf of the choice deliberately choose to adhere and creams containing natural formulas that you keep the fault

[extra jel]

As millions of people who want to lose weight, but youDid he can not succeed in a kind of worry about your weight yanıyorsunuz more? You might think, and this process will be much easier to lose weight in a healthy way to get over ... Now a much more difficult as it used to have a nice view, but you have to do is that you want to attenuation.

[ゼチーア]

Hi there,
Really nice job,There are many people searching about that now they will find enough sources by your tips.
Also looking forward for more tips about that

[Asics Tiger]

The nomination of the winner depends on the capability and spirit of the personality to finish the race.I like the post very much as it contain informative in knowledge.

[New Era Caps Wholesale]

I like pics of Chelsea shares of the beauty of running in Madison, Wisconsin.I want to congratulate the winner for the nomination race.I want to know suggestion from others.

[logo design]

I read the news and I was hopping you talk about it here.
amazing, I'm waiting for more news about Bio diesel from Algae.
thanks a lot .

[Office 2010]

I enjoyed studying your blog. Keep it that way.

[club marian]

It takes lots of hard work to put together the the evidence and make the regressions work. I have got my PhD in Econ and have done a lot of the data crunching, my experience is that the one who has done most writing / most data crunching comes in the front, those who have merely provided comments / advices / guidance comes in the back.